Ep. 209 - 13 Years of Failed Housing Crash Predictions EXPLAINED
Oct 28, 2024The real estate market has consistently ignored crash predictions since 2012. Each year brought new theories - from shadow inventory concerns to manufacturing recessions - yet the market continued its upward trajectory. From 2012 to 2013, home prices increased by 17% despite rising mortgage rates. This pattern of growth persisted through various economic challenges, including the end of quantitative easing and reaching previous bubble highs.
Looking back to 1942, the housing market has experienced only one year of negative growth (-1%) outside the 2007-2011 recession. This remarkable stability spans multiple economic cycles, interest rate environments, and demographic shifts, demonstrating the fundamental strength of real estate as an asset class.
The Missing Pieces for a Market Crash
Today's housing market lacks two critical elements that were present in the 2008 crash: distressed sellers and low equity positions. Current homeowners possess significant equity in their properties and maintain strong control over their selling decisions. This fundamental difference creates a market dynamic where price drops are unlikely, even with reduced transaction volume.
The relationship between sales volume and prices isn't as straightforward as many suggest. While sales volumes have decreased due to higher mortgage rates, prices haven't followed suit because sellers aren't forced to accept lower offers. This stability reflects a market driven by choice rather than necessity, contrasting sharply with the forced sales that characterized the 2008 crisis.
Debunking Social Media Housing Myths
The housing crash predictions on social media platforms reveals more about content creation incentives than market realities. Many online predictors lack credentials, historical accuracy, or transparent methodologies. Their success in attracting viewers stems from playing into the hopes of potential homebuyers waiting for price drops.
Seasonal price adjustments are often misrepresented as evidence of market decline. While home prices typically show some seasonal variation, particularly in the second half of the year, these normal fluctuations shouldn't be confused with long-term price trends. The market's annual appreciation remains positive despite these regular seasonal patterns.
Bottom Line
The housing market's resilience in the face of higher mortgage rates reflects fundamental strengths rather than warning signs. With homeowners maintaining strong equity positions and no surge in distressed sales, the market lacks the key ingredients for a crash. Understanding these dynamics helps cut through the noise of social media predictions and focuses attention on real market fundamentals. While the pace of sales may vary with economic conditions, the long-term stability of home prices appears well-supported by current market structures and demographic trends.