LISTEN TO THE SHOW

Ep. 174 - Credit Score Myths Busted | What You Don't Know Can Hurt You

Jun 30, 2024

 Credit scores play a crucial role in our financial lives, yet many misconceptions persist about how they work. Recent findings from VantageScore, a credit scoring model gaining traction among lenders, have shed new light on some common credit myths. Understanding these insights can help you make more informed decisions about managing your credit.

 

One of the most surprising revelations is the outsized impact that credit card payments can have on your score compared to other types of debt. While many assume a mortgage is the most important factor, missing a credit card payment can actually cause a more severe drop in your score than missing a car loan or personal loan payment. This is especially true when credit cards are near their limits.

 

The Importance of Payment History

Your payment history remains one of the most critical factors in determining your credit score. However, the impact of a missed payment can vary significantly depending on your overall credit profile. For those with a long history of on-time payments, a single missed payment on an installment loan like a mortgage or auto loan may have less impact than missing a credit card payment.

 

This doesn't mean you should prioritize credit card payments over your mortgage. In fact, for those with clean credit histories, missing a mortgage payment can still result in the most severe score drop. The key takeaway is that all payments matter, but credit card payments deserve special attention due to their potential for outsized negative impact.

 

Credit Utilization: A Key Factor

How much of your available credit you're using, known as credit utilization, is another crucial factor in your credit score. Maxing out credit cards can be particularly damaging to your score. If you come into some extra money and want to improve your credit, paying down high-balance credit cards is often the most effective strategy.

 

Interestingly, closing a credit card after paying it off can actually hurt your score by reducing your overall available credit. It's generally better to keep accounts open, even if you're not actively using them. This helps maintain a longer credit history and lower overall utilization rate.

 

Building Credit: Start Early and Smart

For young adults just starting to build credit, there are smart strategies to establish a solid foundation. Student credit cards can be a good entry point, as they often have more lenient approval requirements. The key is to use these cards responsibly – making small purchases and paying the balance in full each month.

 

Parents can give their children a head start by adding them as authorized users on their own credit cards. This allows the child to benefit from the parent's established credit history. However, it's crucial that parents only do this if they themselves have good credit habits, as negative information can also be passed along.

 

Credit Inquiries and New Accounts

While not as impactful as payment history or credit utilization, applying for new credit can also affect your score. Multiple credit inquiries in a short period can signal financial distress to lenders. However, the scoring models typically treat multiple inquiries for the same type of loan (like a mortgage) within a short timeframe as a single inquiry, recognizing that you're rate shopping.

 

Opening several new accounts in a short period can also lower your average account age, potentially impacting your score. It's generally best to space out new credit applications and only apply for credit you truly need.

 

Bottom Line

Understanding the nuances of credit scoring can help you make better financial decisions. While it's important to manage all your debts responsibly, paying special attention to credit card balances and payments can have an outsized positive impact on your credit score. Start building credit early, use it wisely, and always strive to make payments on time to maintain a healthy credit profile.